The Rose and the Dagger

The Rose and the Dagger

Book - 2016
Average Rating:
11
Rate this:
"Unsure who to trust, Shahrzad takes matters into her own hands to try and break the curse and reunite with her one true love"--Provided by publisher.
Publisher: New York : G.P. Putnam's Sons, c2016
ISBN: 9780399171628
Branch Call Number: YA FIC AHD
Characteristics: 416 p. :,map ;,22 cm.

Opinion

From the critics


Community Activity

Comment

Add a Comment

t
TEENREVIEWBOARD
Oct 23, 2017

***SPOILERS***
In comparison to the first book, this one was equally satisfying to read. I adore the protagonist in her fiery devotion and selflessness, and the scenarios she is put in are honestly trivial. The plot is an amazing carpet of fibres and colours, blended with the characters' acts of power, love, hate, and more. I really felt it when Rahim died, even though I didn't think I would have liked him at all. He wasn't given too much background, but I felt it through Irsa's sorrow. The epilogue was adorable though!
- @Siri of the Teen Review Board of the Hamilton Public Library

m
marthabwaters
Aug 07, 2017

Readers who enjoyed The Wrath and the Dawn will probably be satisfied by this conclusion to the duology. I loved the supporting characters, and I appreciate that Ahdieh struck a nice balance between having a complex and interesting plot without teetering over the line into the territory of the book being too complicated and overstuffed for its own good. (This is a common issue I have with some teen fantasy, and so I always appreciate books that feel like they are exactly the right length with just the right amount of plot for their page count.) I still have a slight issue with the basic premise of this series – I’m all for humanizing villains in retellings, but I think it needs to be noted that Khalid stopped killing his wives only when he fell in love with one of them (WTF, dude?), and that just feels morally squishy to me — but when I set that quibble aside, I think this two-book story was fairly strong YA fantasy.

m
mightyminnie
Jul 03, 2017

Wow this author is amazing! I am loving the story and world she has created.

h
happycanuck
Jun 10, 2017

As good as the last novel so I enjoyed it very much.

PimaLib_ChristineR May 19, 2017

While I felt that The Wrath & The Dawn was complete enough to stand on its own, it was wonderful to have this companion piece with a final conclusion. Ahdieh takes the typical teen trope: Good Girl must choose between the Nice Friend she's known forever and the New Bad Boy, and completely turns it on its head. It isn't that she discards the trope or the basic premise, it's that she makes it so much bigger than "which boy should I choose." We know from the start that Shazi has chosen Khalid, but now it's a question of how she can get back to him, protect her family and prevent a war. And we find out, that like real life, not everyone can get everything they want.

This has surprising moments of despair, and betrayal, that have lasting consequences, before we can get to happiness. As I said, in a lesser writer's hands, this could have been such a stereotype, but the writing is so fresh, descriptive and taught, that it kept me reading well into the night to see what would happen next. It's not every writer who could make you excited and surprised when a flying carpet, well, you know...flies.

Overall I was quite satisfied with this book, it had a compelling and gave a unique twist to the original story of One thousand and one nights. The pacing was a bit slow for me, since it's quite a big novel.
I personally liked characters like Shazi's younger sister and how the plot also focused more than just the two main characters. The new characters were mysterious and definitely added solid extra material. This book has decent romance, adventure and action. I really liked the ending too as it solidly wrapped up the story. There are also some really good elements of plot twist though out to keep the reader alert and engaged.
I think that the book could honestly have some parts of it cut out and the story would have relatively stayed the same. There are still some unanswered questions too that need some explaining. And even though the epilogue was a nice finishing touch, I still hoped that there could be a bit more clarification for certain events for minor characters like Shazi's father and Tariq.
I rate this book as decent
- V.D

it was amazing,

overview: in a land that is on the brink of war, Shahrzad has been torn away from her husband Khalid the Caliph or Khorasan. her husband was cursed by a man. Shahrzad makes it her duty to break the curse and find her way back to her to her love again. but there are new threats at every corner.

what I liked: the writing was amazing, the plot line took twists and turns on every corner!

what I disliked: there was no glossary, some of the words used were not understandable.

this book is awesome for those who are into myths and legends. I personally am fascinated by that kind of stuff. this story is supposed to be about the one thousand and one nights. ( Arabian legend.) I also recommend reading the first book( the wrath and the dawn by Renee Ahdieh) first and then picking this one upon because then the story makes more sense.

I highly recommend this book! if you are into the myths and legends.

- Review from Fleetwood teen A.P.

AL_CATHERINE Dec 15, 2016

This is one of those rare but delightful examples of a sequel that is even better than the first book. Adieh writes fantasy beautifully! I loved the world, magic, and strong characters!

i
Isabellelam
Jul 18, 2016

This sequel was even better than the first book, which is pleasantly surprising for a sequel. The characters shone in their fully glory, and if a great set of characters is not enough to entice you, there are also great action sequences and a few plot twists here and there. I'm incredibly glad the series ended on such a good note.

KateHillier Jun 23, 2016

This is most definitely a case of expecting way too much. The first book was so amazing and awesome I was just assuming this book would be the same. It is in some ways, it's just a lot quieter about it.

Like the first book the reason I stuck with it was Shahrzad, who is still a fierce and uncompromising character no matter what position she finds herself in (and she finds herself in many different ones as this novel goes on). There's a war to be fought (or stopped), lovers to reunite (aside from our main pairing), and a lot to get through conflict wise between people's lies and people's actually goals in this entire saga.

The ending is a bit disappointing to me but, all in all, it was still a good read over all.

View All Comments

Age Suitability

Add Age Suitability

There are no age suitabilities for this title yet.

Summary

Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.

Notices

Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.

Quotes

Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number

Recommendations

Subject Headings

  Loading...

Find it at FVRL

  Loading...
[]
[]
To Top